Writing Prompt for "The First Emperor"


Texts needed for this assessment:


"The First Emperor"

"Digging up the Past"

Read the Prompt

The two selections that you have just read provide different kinds of information on the same topic. In writing assessments, you will often be asked to compare nonfiction selections that deal with a similar topic in different ways.

In three paragraphs, compare the main idea of "The First emperor" and "Digging Up the Past." Remember that the topic of each piece of writing is the same, but each presents different information. Support your comparison using details from each.


What are some strategies that you can use to unpack the prompt?


  • I need to identify the similarities and differences in the main idea of each selection.
  • I need to determine the type of information in each selection.
  • I should include examples from the selections to support my ideas. 

Plan Your Writing

Using the chart you filled out as you read, identify the ways in which the selections are alike and different. then think about how to present these similarities and differences.
  • Decide on a position statement for your response.
  • Review the selections to find details and examples that support your comparison.
  • Create an outline to organize your ideas. This sample outline shows one way to organize your three paragraphs.
I. Introduction with thesis.
II. Main idea of first selection.
III. Main idea of second selection.
IV. Compare main ideas of selections.


Draft Your Response
Paragraph 1: Introduction with title of selection and authors' names. Briefly tell the main idea of each selection.
Paragraph 2: State the main idea of the first selection; include details from the text.
Paragraph 3: State the main idea of the second selection; include details from the text.
Paragraph 4: Compare and contrast the main ideas in each of the selections.
Paragraph 5: Conclusion that is a restatement of the introduction.


Revision Tip

Check that you have used good transitions!






Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

"Scout's Honor" by Avi

Image
I've created a learning resource to go along with the short story that you can find in my shop. My students have been telling me that it's quite difficult. We've done two pages per day as part of our reading workshop minilessons. They're writing the notes and responses in their journals. The grammar connection on infinitives really threw them for a loop~it was the first time that they've encountered this verbal. Melissa
Read more

Back to School Bumper Sticker Activity and Printable

Image
Here in Middle Tennessee, we go back to school in two weeks, so it's the perfect time to begin thinking about icebreaker activities.  My Back to school Bumper Sticker Printable and Activity includes 20 different bumper stickers, 10 color and 10 black and white. There are 2 bumper stickers per page. Use this as an icebreaker in the following way: Students brainstorm some bumper stickers that they've seen and what those bumper stickers say about the person driving the car. Then, the students will write down several bumper sticker sayings that represent them and their ideas or beliefs. Show students some examples of completed bumper stickers. Afterwards, give each student a copy of the bumper sticker template. Each student designs and creates a bumper sticker that represents him or her. After students have created their bumper stickers, they walk around the room reading each other's bumper stickers. This activity is a fun and creati
Read more

LSV: Writing Book Reviews Lesson Plan

Image
You will need the following for this lesson: Examples of  book reviews written by adults and students Check out this site for some great examples. Highlighters, markers, pens, and pencils Copies of close read questions for the reviews Copies of a short story or narrative poem for students to read and review A book review is an in-depth, insightful analysis of a book. An effective review explains what the book is about and usually offers the reviewer's opinion. Begin the lesson by having students do a cold read of a book review. After students have read the book review, ask them to discuss what the book review does for the reader? What is the purpose of the book review? After the students have read and discussed the book review, have students go back through the review and annotate it . Let the students share their annotations with their classmates. The typical book review includes the title of the book, the author's name, a
Read more